Bodies from the Library is one of my most favorite series. Each new one is much awaited and instantly bought.
The stories themselves are great, but the introduction to the author at the end of each story is really well written, and introduces us to some of the other work by the same author.. Which means if we like someone, we can read more of them.
This compilation, however, does not meet the same high standards.
Because every single story ever has been stellar, even a 'normal' crime story kind of appears to be falling short.
Vacancy with corpse, though long, justifies the length.
The Magnifying Glass by Cyril Hare and The Predestined by Q Patrick are the other stories that stand out. Both stand for natural justice.
The year and the day by Edmund Crispin is a delightful, intriguing read.
Murder in Montparnasse has to take the credit for being the most convoluted plot and somehow, magically, it still manages to bore the reader to death.
If you are a Bodies from the Library fan like me, do collect this one. its worth keeping in the library. But if you are just starting out on the genre of Golden Age of Crime Fiction, this is not the right book to start with. Start with Bodies from the Library 1, or the Strand magazine, which, I believe is now free to read somewhere on the internet.